Ernst Lubitsch was a top director in Germany before he was brought to Hollywood by Mary Pickford in 1922. He remained European in his lifestyle and outlook, while his films took on a Hollywood gloss, as he worked with the industry’s top stars, first at Warner Bros., and then mostly at Paramount.
One of Lubitsch’s biggest fans was critic Herman G. Weinberg. The author, critic and columnist carried the torch for the director’s greatness for fifty years, even when the director’s films were out of fashion and could not easily be seen. Weinberg’s final word on Lubitsch was his The Lubitsch Touch: a Critical Study, published in 1968.
Weinberg interviewed Lubitsch in 1929 when the director was in New York, working on the screenplay for what became his first talkie, The Love Parade. Of all the things they discussed, Weinberg documented Lubitsch’s astute commentary on several films he had recently seen.
The Passion of Joan of Arc, directed by Carl-Theodor Dreyer, played art houses in New York.
“Very interesting,” he said, “but Dreyer seemed to me a little too much obsessed by form. He seemed more concerned with the mechanics of the photography, with the composition of the individual scenes, than with the context of the piece, which, after all, should be a director’s first problem.
“Dreyer’s method of telling the film-story in closeups is too studied, too deliberate and obvious and becomes, after a fashion, wearying. Of course, the film shows occasional flashes of
absolute genius and a knowledge of cinematics but, as a whole, it left me cold.
After a discussion of Soviet filmmaking, and some scenes in Pudovkin’s Storm Over Asia, Lubitsch discussed King Vidor’s The Crowd.
He has great admiration for Chaplin and admires A Woman of Paris very much. He thinks that The Crowd is a great picture and deserved much more critical attention than it got.
“But the trouble with The Crowd in America was this,” he said, “Americans don’t understand its theme of futility, or what is still worse, don’t want to understand it. Europeans are not quite attuned to the system here and are equally in the dark. It is only the European in America, who knows Americans and midde-class American life, who can understand The Crowd.”
Read the entire interview in the September 1929 issue of Movie Makers.